Ethereum layer-2 options could focus much less on token incentives sooner or later

5 minutes, 42 seconds Read

Layer-2 networks proceed to achieve momentum because the Ethereum ecosystem advances. For instance, information from analytics supplier Token Terminal discovered that layer-2 scaling answer Polygon had 313,457 day by day energetic customers as of Jan. 17, 2023 — a 30% improve in exercise since October 2022. 

Furthermore, the Polygon ecosystem just lately introduced the launch of its beta model Zero-Information Ethereum Digital Machine. In consequence, Polygon’s native token, Polygon (MATIC), maintains a bullish narrative.

Whereas notable, some consider layer-2 networks providing token incentive fashions could quickly turn into out of date. As an illustration, Jesse Pollak — head of protocols and Base core contributor at American crypto change Coinbase — instructed Cointelegraph at ETHDenver 2023 that there are at present no plans to affiliate a token with Base, the Ethereum layer-2 community just lately launched by Coinbase. He mentioned:

“We take into consideration tokens as a strong incentive instrument that may change consumer and developer habits. On the similar time, we have now seen conditions unfold over the previous couple of years the place tokens have been used as an incentive mechanism with an absence of product match for the underlying chain. Tokens have additionally resulted in nefarious or dangerous conditions prior to now.”

In accordance with Pollak, Base is a layer-2 answer that permits builders to simply construct functions with out requiring an incentive mechanism. “Our product will stand by itself. Will probably be very straightforward for builders to make use of to construct functions and distribute these to actual human beings,” he mentioned.

Shifting focus from token fashions to consumer expertise

Specializing in ease of use and distribution are essential factors, as Pollak identified that a lot of right this moment’s decentralized functions have been used solely for buying and selling cryptocurrencies. “Buying and selling will not be sufficient to make cryptocurrency the way forward for the financial system. At Base, we’re making it straightforward for builders to construct helpful functions that folks truly wish to use,” he added.

Pollak defined that Base is investing in core infrastructure, akin to Ethereum Enchancment Proposal 4844, which is able to make the community safe and low-cost in contrast with different layer-2 networks. “It prices about 10–15 cents to conduct transactions on layer-2s. We goal to deliver that down,” he talked about.

Whereas Base launched its testnet in February, Pollak shared that the Base mainnet launch will happen within the coming months. Furthermore, whereas no plans exist for Base to supply a local token, a number of ecosystem individuals have already expressed curiosity in constructing on Base.

Current: Subsequent cease Shanghai — Ethereum’s newest milestone approaches

For instance, Konstantin Richter, chief working officer and founding father of Blockdaemon — a blockchain infrastructure supplier — instructed Cointelegraph at ETHDenver 2023 that Blockdaemon will function an official infrastructure accomplice for Base. Richter shared that he thinks Base shouldn’t have a token related to the community, as he believes proof-of-stake (PoS) is a wholly damaged system. “Blockdaemon runs extra PoS nodes than anybody else, and I can inform you that proof-of-stake solely works when token costs go up,” he mentioned.

Richter additional defined that Blockdaemon plans to make use of the Base community to find out tips on how to permit community individuals to run nodes whereas presumably incomes a hard and fast U.S. greenback payment. “This will end in a special kind of PoS mechanism, presumably round dedication of compute relatively than a staked share of tokens that will not serve the community nicely,” he mentioned. Richter added that such a mannequin may end in a greater consumer expertise. He mentioned:

“This could possibly be the most important paradigm shift inside the cryptocurrency ecosystem because the invention of PoS. We’re transferring away from incentive fashions that reward customers for utilizing a product. We at the moment are targeted on ease of performance and low charges.”

But it stays questionable how precisely Base will appeal to customers and builders to the platform with no token incentive mannequin. Given Coinbase’s huge understanding of establishments and decentralized finance (DeFi), Richter doesn’t suppose this must be a difficulty: “I want to work with Base given Coinbase’s understanding of establishments and DeFi. It’s outstanding {that a} public Fortune 500 firm is dedicated to placing transactions transparently on Base.”

Whereas it’s too quickly to foretell future outcomes, it’s essential to notice that Arbitrum, one other Ethereum layer-2 community, additionally features with no native token. This has actually not stopped customers from interacting with the Arbitrum community. In accordance with information from the analytics web site, Arbitrum has about $3.35 billion complete worth locked, making up about 54% of the market share on Ethereum.

Nonetheless, rumors have been circulating that Arbitrum could provoke a token airdrop sooner or later. Whereas this may increasingly or not be the case, it demonstrates Arbitrum’s capability to find out product market match earlier than launching a token. Gil Rosen, president of the Stanford Blockchain Accelerator, instructed Cointelegraph at ETHDenver 2023 that discovering product market match is about making certain tasks purchase the correct prospects whose worth is accretive to the ecosystem, which regularly isn’t the case with tokens. “Early tasks that launch tokens are sometimes locked into tokenomics fashions earlier than discovering product market match after which are unable to pivot dynamically,” Rosen mentioned.

“DeFi Dad,” a accomplice at digital asset funding agency Fourth Revolution Capital, instructed Cointelegraph that he believes the primary driver behind layer-2 tokens is to make sure decentralized management over layer-2 networks.

For instance, he defined that the upcoming launch of zkSync’s Zero-Information Ethereum Digital Machine would use a PoS mechanism to permit zkSync tokenholders to behave as stakers. “Layer-2 tokens are crucial for constructing the decentralized future,” he mentioned.

DeFi Dad thinks a layer-2 community with out plans to implement a local token could possibly be profitable if customers are keen to sacrifice decentralization and censorship resistance within the quick time period. 

Current: Banks with crypto providers require new Anti-Cash Laundering capabilities

He mentioned, “Base could possibly be profitable as a community for transacting with a consumer’s crypto. Nonetheless, make no mistake; Base might be a layer-2 (a minimum of for the foreseeable future) that makes trade-offs. As DeFi customers, we are inclined to deprioritize safety and censorship resistance till we actually want it.”

With this level in thoughts, Rosen talked about that he believes token fashions will stay for a lot of decentralized tasks with giant developer and consumer communities, however these will launch later. “A venture could launch a token when the networks themselves are extra mature and have discovered product market match.”